The Teacher and the Student: Four Years of Arsenal vs. Pep — and Why It Always Ends the Same
Arteta learned everything Guardiola could teach him. Yet for four seasons he keeps losing in the spring. The data explains why.
Do you know that feeling when you can see exactly what’s about to happen — and it happens anyway? Arsenal fans know it. Every single year. A little hope in autumn, a little more in winter. Then spring arrives. And with it, always the same story: a few points dropped, a game that turns, a headline that cuts like a knife.
From July 2016 to December 2019, Mikel Arteta was Pep’s assistant manager. Three and a half years in Manchester. Two Premier League titles, side by side. Pep wanted to groom him as his successor. Arteta wasn’t just any assistant — he was the man standing next to Guardiola while City dismantled every other team in the league. And since then, the student has been trying to beat the teacher. Four seasons. Same result.
The data from the final ten matchdays each season tells this story more clearly than any headline. Two lines. One swings wildly. The other stays flat. That is the structural truth of this rivalry.
What these curves show: 2022/23 — the collapse. Arsenal finish on 15 points after 10 games, 4 dropped from winning positions. 2023/24 — the counter-argument: 25 points, zero dropped leads. And still not enough. Because on the other side stands the same machine.
Three comeback points per season — from Liverpool, Crystal Palace, Crystal Palace (23/24), Liverpool (25/26). In these weeks City collects exactly the same number of points every year that others would leave behind. Not spectacular. Just reliable.
Comparing all teams shows this clearly: Arsenal are by no means a mid-table finisher in the run-in. In 23/24 they were the second-best team in the entire league over those final ten games. But City were better in three of four seasons — and the one time it was close (25 vs. 28 in 23/24), it still wasn’t enough for the title.
22/23 was the year that shaped everything. Arsenal led by five points — and lost by five in the end. Not because City caught up. But because Arsenal fell apart. Liverpool 2:2, West Ham 2:2, Southampton 3:3. Four points dropped from winning positions in three games. That’s not bad luck. That’s a collapse.
This is the harder version of the story nobody else tells. Arteta didn’t bottle it. Arsenal didn’t mess it up every year. They did what they could in four consecutive title races — sometimes more, sometimes less, but never so little it would disappoint a champion in a normal era.
The problem is that they’re not playing in a normal era. They’re playing against the manager Arteta learned to win from. And the teacher has a higher ceiling than his best student. City collect the same points every year in these weeks that Arsenal leave behind. Not spectacularly. Just reliably. And in a title race, that is the most brutal thing that can happen to you.
The league is mathematically open. One City slip-up is enough. But hoping for that means waiting for something that hasn’t happened in four seasons. Two lines. One swings. The other stays flat. That is this rivalry in numbers.
Frequently Asked Questions
More Football Analysis on YouTube
Data-driven stories from the Premier League, Bundesliga and Champions League — new every week.
Subscribe to Pogobonito